Login Subscribe
    • Players/Parents
    • College Coaches
  • Alabama
    Arizona
    Arkansas
    California
    Colorado
    Dakotas
    Florida
    Georgia
    Illinois
    Indiana
    Iowa
    Kansas
    Kentucky
    Louisiana
    Maryland
    Michigan
    Minnesota
    Missouri
    Nebraska
    New England
    New Jersey
    New Mexico
    New York
    North Carolina
    Ohio
    Oklahoma
    Oregon
    South Carolina
    Tennessee
    Texas
    Utah
    Virginia
    Washington
    West Virginia
    Wisconsin
  • Loading...
  • Tournaments
    • Prep Girls Hoops Circuit Prep Girls Hoops Circuit
    Showcases
    • Freshman Showcase Freshman Showcase
    • Sophomore ID Camp Sophomore ID Camp
    • The Expo The Expo
    About Our Events
  • Prep Girls Hoops for
    • Players
    • Parents
    • Club Coaches
    • High School Coaches
    • College Coaches
    • Fans
    View All Features
    • Coverage Access Prep Girls Hoops articles year-round without ads.
    • Rankings See how players stack up in each state.
    • Player Profiles Build your own profile and join the Prep Girls Hoops database.
    • Coach Views Get notified when a college coach views your profile.
    • Profile Trends Track your Player Profile views over time.
    • Recruiting Tasks Stay on-track in the recruiting process
    • Recruiting Dashboard All your recruiting tools in a single place.
    • College Match Recommends colleges that match with your profile.
    • Coach Contacts Contact any program in the country.
    • Event Credits Save $25 on all Prep Girls Hoops showcases.
    • Recruiting Tips Become an expert on the recruiting process.
    • College Email Templates Send customized emails directly to college coaches.
  • Wisconsin
  • Rankings
    • How We Rank

    • HS Power Rankings

    • Archived Rankings

    • 2026 Rankings

    • 2027 Rankings

    • 2028 Rankings

  • Player Database
  • Teams
    • High Schools

    • Club Programs

  • Scores
  • Scouts
  • Home
  • Coverage
      Alabama
      Arizona
      Arkansas
      California
      Colorado
      Dakotas
      Florida
      Georgia
      Illinois
      Indiana
      Iowa
      Kansas
      Kentucky
      Louisiana
      Maryland
      Michigan
      Minnesota
      Missouri
      Nebraska
      New England
      New Jersey
      New Mexico
      New York
      North Carolina
      Ohio
      Oklahoma
      Oregon
      South Carolina
      Tennessee
      Texas
      Utah
      Virginia
      Washington
      West Virginia
      Wisconsin
  • Events
      Tournaments
      • Prep Girls Hoops Circuit Prep Girls Hoops Circuit
      Showcases
      • Freshman Showcase Freshman Showcase
      • Sophomore ID Camp Sophomore ID Camp
      • The Expo The Expo
      About Our Events
  • Rankings
      Loading...
  • Features
      Prep Girls Hoops for
      • Players
      • Parents
      • Club Coaches
      • High School Coaches
      • College Coaches
      • Fans
      View All Features
      • Coverage Access Prep Girls Hoops articles year-round without ads.
      • Rankings See how players stack up in each state.
      • Player Profiles Build your own profile and join the Prep Girls Hoops database.
      • Coach Views Get notified when a college coach views your profile.
      • Profile Trends Track your Player Profile views over time.
      • Recruiting Tasks Stay on-track in the recruiting process
      • Recruiting Dashboard All your recruiting tools in a single place.
      • College Match Recommends colleges that match with your profile.
      • Coach Contacts Contact any program in the country.
      • Event Credits Save $25 on all Prep Girls Hoops showcases.
      • Recruiting Tips Become an expert on the recruiting process.
      • College Email Templates Send customized emails directly to college coaches.
  • Support
Login Subscribe

Which Players Have Surprised Us Most?

Which Players Have Surprised Us Most?
Brady Peterson
Brady Peterson December 5, 2023 @ 09:50 AM
Facebook
X (Formerly Twitter)

In this article:

Princess Nwachukwu
Princess Nwachukwu 5'11" | C | 2025
WI
Serenity Metcalfe
Serenity Metcalfe 5'8" | CG | 2025
WI
Kylie Butler
Kylie Butler 5'7" | CG | 2026
WI
Mackenzie Tarman
Mackenzie Tarman 6'0" | SF | 2024
WI
<!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>After recapping my weekend yesterday, I want to continue reflecting by highlighting some surprises. To start, we'll talk about some teams that have been better than expected. Afterward, we'll discuss players to close the day out.</p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --> <!-- wp:paragraph --> <p><strong>[player_tooltip player_id='844201' first='Serenity' last='Metcalfe']</strong></p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --> <!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>Not many kids could score north of 40 points in a game if you gave them every shot their team took. Metcalfe is a kid who moved up to Shorewood from Alabama a few years ago and has been one of the most consistent scorers in the state. Some will overlook it because she's not doing it with a team that has any reputation, but she's been scoring with plenty of volume early on in the season.</p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --> <!-- wp:paragraph --> <p><strong>[player_tooltip player_id='521879' first='Mackenzie' last='Tarman']</strong></p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --> <!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>Tarman has been one of the best small-school scorers in the past few seasons. The Turtle Lake wing has an effortless jumper and the green light to let it fly whenever she's open. She's been integral in some early season wins for the Turtles because of the 30 points per game she's added to her team's point tally each night. She'd be a steal for any small school looking for a competitive 5-11 wing who can score it at a high level.</p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --> <!-- wp:paragraph --> <p><strong>[player_tooltip player_id='844208' first='Princess' last='Nwachukwu']</strong></p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --> <!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>I thought guard play would be the recipe for Vel Phillips Memorial to win games, but Nwachukwu has been the force in the Spartans' excellent start to the season. She's been outstanding at the base of the 2-3 Spartan defense and has been as good of a rim protector as you'd find in the Madison area. I've loved the tone she's been able to set for the Spartans on the end of the floor, and I'd say she's been the main reason they've been as good as they've been.</p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --> <!-- wp:paragraph --> <p><strong>[player_tooltip player_id='767257' first='Kylie' last='Butler']</strong></p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --> <!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>I saw Butler twice this summer before she transferred to Argyle. I loved her passing and ability to close out games by scoring, passing, not turning the ball over, and understanding situational basketball. She's got a high basketball IQ, and it shows when she's on the floor. Her passing range is as good as anyone in the state, and she'll throw full-court passes if she thinks the window is there. Butler can score 25 on any night but is more than happy to distribute if she's not making shots. Her presence has been the difference between this season and last for Argyle/Pecatonica.</p> <!-- /wp:paragraph -->

After recapping my weekend yesterday, I want to continue reflecting by highlighting some surprises. To start, we'll talk about some teams that have been better than expected. Afterward, we'll discuss players to close the day out.

Prep Girls Hoops

Access all of Prep Girls Hoops

Continue reading this article and more.

Continue Reading
Already a subscriber? Log in

Rankings

100 Players Ranked

  • 1
    Adaline Sheplee

    Adaline Sheplee

    Rice Lake

  • 2
    Natalie Kussow

    Natalie Kussow

    Arrowhead

  • 3
    Leah Nordin

    Leah Nordin

    Shawano

    Wisconsin
  • 4
    Giselle Janowski

    Giselle Janowski

    Pewaukee

    Wisconsin
  • 5
    Mikaia Litza

    Mikaia Litza

    Wauwatosa East

    DePaul
View Full Rankings

Related Articles

  • Recognized by Their Role Models: Ferris Elite Camp MVPs

    Recognized by Their Role Models: Ferris Elite Camp MVPs

    Danyle Bowers • August 6

  • Players Who Could Take a Leap in 2025-26

    Players Who Could Take a Leap in 2025-26

    Brady Peterson • August 6

  • Newcomers to Know Before the 2025-26 Season

    Newcomers to Know Before the 2025-26 Season

    Brady Peterson • August 6

  • 2027 Recruitments I’m Following

    2027 Recruitments I’m Following

    Brady Peterson • August 5

  • 17U All-AAU Teams and Superlatives

    17U All-AAU Teams and Superlatives

    Brady Peterson • August 5

Loading...
Home Wisconsin Which Players Have Surprised Us Most?

Prep Network

  • Prep Dig
  • Prep Girls Hoops
  • Prep Hoops
  • Prep Lacrosse
  • Prep Redzone
  • Prep Soccer
  • Prep Softball

Company

  • News
  • Careers
  • Store
  • Partner Interest Form

Resources

  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Accessibility
  • Cookie Policy
  • Recruiting Tips
  • Student Loan Resources
  • College Scholarship Search

Support

  • My Account
  • Contact
  • Sitemap

© 2025 Prep Girls Hoops. All rights reserved.