Natalie Thomas
Natalie Thomas
About Natalie
Expert Analysis
Darvoni Christopher | Prep Girls Hoops Scout
Senior center
Natalie Thomas
Natalie
Thomas
6'2" | C/PF
Fishers | 2026
State
IN
, a Bethel University commit, has gotten off to a strong offensive start this season, currently averaging 12.6 points per game. She consistently puts herself in positions to either score efficiently or make smart passes, often finding teammates in the corners or wings for open threes. Watching her in action is exciting—her footwork, agility, and court awareness make her a difficult matchup in the paint, creating constant problems for opposing defenses like Westfield. Thomas elevated her performance against Westfield, finishing the night with 14 points, exceeding her season average. Her combination of scoring ability, vision, and leadership has already made a big impact this year, and it will be exciting to see how she continues to perform throughout her senior season.
Access all of Prep Girls Hoops
Subscribe to read about this player
Read EvaluationDarvoni Christopher | Prep Girls Hoops Scout
Last season marked
Natalie Thomas
Natalie
Thomas
6'2" | C/PF
Fishers | 2026
State
IN
‘s first year playing consistently at the varsity level for the Tigers, and she quickly proved she was ready for the challenge. With her size and length, she was able to cover space defensively, making it difficult for opponents to score against her. Over the past AAU season, Thomas expanded her offensive game, showing her ability to run the floor and score in transition, finish around the basket, and hit shots from the elbow. She also displayed range beyond the arc, adding another layer to her versatility. Thomas recently committed to Bethel University, where she projects as one of the program’s most promising recruits in her class. At the high school level, she helped the Tigers to a 14–9 record last season, and entering this year, she is expected to take another step forward as a scorer while leading a young roster toward continued success.
Access all of Prep Girls Hoops
Subscribe to read about this player
Read EvaluationBrandon Bradley | Prep Girls Hoops Scout
The number of traditional posts in the world are nearing extinction, but Natalie does a really nice job of using that to her advantage and creating mismatches. She likes physicality, but she also possesses solid balance, good ball skill, and the ability to turn either direction and finish with a couple of post moves each way. She plays hard/runs the floor hard, and she is engaged and effortful defensively. She also has a little face-up capability as well.
Access all of Prep Girls Hoops
Subscribe to read about this player
Read EvaluationBrandon Bradley | Prep Girls Hoops Scout
Until she attended “The Expo” this Fall, I hadn’t seen Natalie in a while, as she had dealt with some injury issues. But she performed well at the event, looked leaner but still strong, and she showed the ability to play around the block and use her size or step out and play effectively in the mid-post. She has a strong understanding of the game, she’ll work hard at either end of the floor, and she likes contact but shows some finesse as well. A strong Winter and Spring should help her pick up a lot of nice small college interest, considering her size and skill.
Access all of Prep Girls Hoops
Subscribe to read about this player
Read EvaluationBrandon Bradley | Prep Girls Hoops Scout
Paired with 6-2 8th Grader
Adah Hupfer
Adah
Hupfer
6'3" | C
Pendleton Heights | 2027
State
IN
, Natalie helps form a monstrous interior duo for their grassroots team. Natalie has broad shoulders, a strong frame, and she can establish herself with ease against her peers at either end of the floor. She doesn’t mind contact and will move people around, but she has also shown soft hands, she can finish in a variety of ways at the basket, plus she has shown some touch facing the basket to near the 3-point line. With three more years in front of her before college, she will probably always be defined as a “post”, but she can certainly develop into a face-up ‘5’ who can either pick-and-roll or pick-and-pop in a Fishers program that has a number of talented guards who I’m sure love her as a ball-screener.
Access all of Prep Girls Hoops
Subscribe to read about this player
Read EvaluationPlayer Claimed
News
Recruiting
- School
- Offer?
- Visit
- Offer graphic